Something new today. This article is a follow-up to a podcast I just did with Ryan Nanni. Maybe read this first? Maybe listen to the podcast first? Not sure the right order, but they certainly go well with each other. Enjoy!

You already know the Ohio State University and Bowling Green State University (BGSU) are public universities in the same state. You know their football teams play in the same subdivision of the same sport. Which means they are both expected to compete for the same championship, year after year. But in fiscal year 2025, Ohio State’s athletic department reported $336.1 million in revenue while BGSU reported $35.3 million. Ohio State’s football program alone brought in $160.6 million, 4.6 times what BGSU’s entire department took in. They spent $92.4 million on football against BGSU’s $11.9 million. I could go on but you get the picture.

The two departments are also financed in different ways. Ohio State reported no student fees and no net support from its university. BGSU collected $14.1 million in student fees and $8.2 million in direct institutional support, which together supplied 63% of its revenue. This isn’t anything new. Measured in dollars, the distance between them has nearly doubled: Ohio State’s revenue exceeded BGSU by $160 million in fiscal 2017 and by $301 million in fiscal 2025.

Ohio State’s athletic department is 9.5 times the size of Bowling Green’s

Why talk about Ohio State and BGSU? No change in the rules will make these two programs equal – I have no delusion about that. That doesn’t mean we can’t do better than the system we have now. The question I took up with Ryan Nanni for an episode of the podcast Phantom Island was narrower: whether the Football Bowl Subdivision can remain a single league of 138 teams in which most members have a realistic chance to compete or whether it will continue to drift toward a two-conference super league. We came up with four ideas to move the sport to the former rather than the latter. Those ideas are:

  1. End guarantee games against the Football Championship Subdivision

  2. Pool media rights

  3. Change College Football Playoff (CFP) revenue distribution

  4. Replace the cap on athlete pay with a luxury tax

Versions of the last three are already in motion. The Senate has passed a bill that would permit pooled media rights. The CFP sold an expanded field to ESPN on Nov. 9 without changing how the money is divided. The Big Ten has adopted, and the SEC has proposed, spending limits enforced by escalating fines, which amounts to a luxury tax. This issue sets out the case for each and tests it against the financial reports that public universities file with the NCAA.

Two economies in one subdivision

Ohio State and BGSU sit near opposite ends of the subdivision. Among the 115 public members with a fiscal 2025 report in the NILnomics database, Ohio State ranked second in revenue and first in football spending. Meanwhile BGSU ranked 97th of 114 in football spending. The divide they illustrate runs through the whole membership. The median Power 4 department took in $175.7 million and the median Group of Six department $48.3 million, a ratio of 3.6 to 1. Median football spending was $50.7 million in the Power 4 and $14.2 million in the Group of Six.

The typical Power 4 department is 3.6 times the size of the typical Group of Six department

The larger difference lies in where the money comes from. Student fees and school support account for $55 of every $100 in Group of Six revenue, or $1.81 billion in fiscal 2025. For the Power 4, it is $8 of every $100. Media rights and conference, NCAA, and bowl payouts account for $32 of every $100 in the Power 4 and $12 in the Group of Six, or about $58.9 million and $6.6 million per school.

Of every $100 in Group of Six revenue, $55 comes from the campus

Half of the subdivision, in other words, is already financed largely by transfers: from students, from university budgets and, as the next section shows, from the larger programs on its schedule. The proposals that follow would not introduce subsidy to college football. They would change who provides it.

📽 NILnomics Does Video 📽

We put out a weekly, 3 minute video breaking down a timely college sports business topic. Fun, easy to understand, and something to share with your friends. Here’s the latest:

Instagram post

We’re on all the major social media channels:

I hope you’ll check them out and subscribe to the channel.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to NILnomics to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right